Court Imposes Israeli Law on Gibraltar Gambling Website

An Israeli Magistrate’s Court ruled last week that the operation of a Gibraltar-based gambling website constitutes a criminal offence in Israel under Israeli law (Israeli Police v. Michael Carlton (in Hebrew)). The website, VictorChandler.com is based in Gibraltar, where gambling is legal. Judge Abraham Hyman reasoned that the website targeted Israeli customers by providing a Hebrew interface and advertising on billboards in Israel, and is therefore deemed to have operated in Israel, despite the foreign location of its web servers and corporate headquarters. Judge Hyman added, that in the context of online commerce the locus of the activity is the end user’s PC (country of destination rule), as opposed to the Website’s servers or corporate establishment (country of origin rule). Judge Hyman’s decision tackles the dense problem of personal jurisdiction in the online environment. The law usually allocates jurisdiction according to the geographical location of the activity or one of the parties (typically, the defendant). Yet, as Joel Reidenberg once explained, “the entire architecture of the Internet is based on the principle of geographic indeterminacy”. Determining where a particular action took place (between websites, advertisers, hosts, servers, routers, end users’ PC) is very difficult in cyberspace. Indeed, Michael Geist named his 2001 article on the subject “Is There a There There? Toward Greater Certainty Internet Jurisdiction” (BERKELEY TECH. L.J. 1345 (2001)), questioning whether any useful distinctions can be made based on geographical location in cyberspace. The Israeli court’s application of a country of destination rule is not surprising, particularly given this was a matter of consumer protection and criminal law, where the law of the forum typically prevails. Judge Hyman referred to the Yahoo v. LICRA affair, where Yahoo sought protection from an American court against enforcement of a French court’s judgment for violation of French laws prohibiting the sale of Nazi-era memorabilia. Judge Hyman effectively applied a “targeting test”, imposing jurisdiction due to the Website’s “purposeful availment” of its services in Israel. The targeting and purposeful availment tests are taken from US jurisprudence on the topic, namely the oft-cited Zippo test (Zippo Mfr. Co. v. Zippo Dot Com, Inc., 952 F. Supp. 1119 (W.D. Pa. 1997)), the Calder test (Calder v. Jones, 465 U.S. 783 (1984)), and Professor Geist’s own contractual  and technological targeting tests. The problematic aspects of such extensions of jurisdictions are clear: criminalizing activities which may be legal where performed, issuing unenforceable decisions (e.g., the Yahoo case itself), and instigating potential diplomatic incidents.

36 Responses to “Court Imposes Israeli Law on Gibraltar Gambling Website”

  1. Teens For Cash Videos Says:

    Teens For Cash Videos

    Teens For Cash Videos

  2. Tony Says:

    Great post.

  3. Jerry Says:

    It’s amazing how these governments want to punish gambling companies in foreign lands.

  4. Delitos Informáticos » Blog Archive » Jurisdicción y delitos en la red Says:

    […] es un interesante caso publicado en el blog de Omer Tene sobre un juez israelí aplicando sus normas jurídicas que consideran delito la actividad de juegos de azar pero a un sitio de gambling localizado en […]

  5. Sara Bareilles - Love Song Says:

    Sara Bareilles – Love Song

    Sara Bareilles – Love Song

  6. Au Pair Says:

    very nice web site. My English is not so good, so I do not understandt it well, but it seems very good. Thanks

  7. Jurestriction : Asserting Ignorance (and Jurisdiction) Says:

    […] [Again, most court decisions lead to Hebrew links, sorry, originally posted in Hebrew] A Kentucky Court ordered, in a wrong and misunderstood decision, to forefeit one hundred and forty one domain which were somewhat involved in gambling into the hands of the State of Kentucky. In the decision, granted by the Kentucky Circuit Court, asserted that since the domains were accessible to Kentucky residents, they could be seen as operating illegal gambling in Kentucky (and therefore asserting jurisdiction) and they could be forfeited in order to stop the plague. (81-CI-1409 Commonwealth of the State of Kentucky v. 141 Internet Domain Names) (and see also the Carlton Case CR 90861/07 Michael Gary Carlton v. Israeli Police and Dr. Omer Tene’s explanation on Carlton) […]

  8. Stewart Engelman Domain Sales Says:

    All of this touches on a very complex issue, that applies to internet marketing and site activities, and goes beyond gambling specifically.

    If a web site is offering services that are legal in the situs of corporate registration of the business that owns the web site, then it would seem to me that the web site is doing nothing wrong by marketing internationally, as long as it does not target market to jurisdictions where its activities are not legal. The mere fact that a resident of a country where that site’s activities are not legal “signs up” should not impose legal liability on the site owner, as long as reasonable due diligence is taken to avoid providing the offending service to that individual (such as restricting offending site services based on the applicant’s stated country of residence).

    In the case cited, I tend to agree with the magistrate’s application of the country of destination concept, due to the site owner’s behavior in marketing the site to Israeli citizens. I’m referring here to the Hebrew mirror site, as well as the local advertising billboards. This shows a deliberate exercise of bad faith of the site owner with respect to Israeli law, and thus justifies legal action on the part of Israeli authorities.

    While I am not familiar with the specifics of Israeli law, it seems Judge Hyman’s opinion is reasonable, using US law as a comparative basis. As an example, when an internet enabled transaction results in a civil dispute between two parties in different US states, there are actually two legal situses involved, that of the plaintiff and that of the defendant. The plaintiff can properly sue in his/her own jurisdiction, and if the defendant refuses to participate by not answering summons, the default judgment against the defendant can be domesticated to the defendant’s jurisdiction of residence. To the extent that Israeli law mirrors US law in this regard (I admit that I don’t know whether it does or doesn’t), Judge Hyman’s opinion would appear to be well founded.

  9. teensforcash Says:

    Can be anything, number of cosmetic?An awe inspiring, wohl klar sein.Sold If you, car Types of.Quote to Julie teensforcash, belonged to the be closed pretty.As the hero, great financing tools.,

  10. Stewart Engelman Domain Sales Says:

    To teensforcash: Could you please explain what you are saying in something remotely resembling English? The only thing I understood was in German (“wohl klar sein” = “well to be clear”), but you are not following your own advice.

  11. Albert Says:

    Hey – whats up. Thanks for the blog. I’ve been digging around for info, but there is so much out there. Google lead me here – good for you i suppose! Keep up the great information. I will be coming back in a few days to see if there is updated posts.

  12. vanity Phone 866 Says:

    Thats nice to now finally locate a site where the blogger really knows what he is talking about.

  13. Jessie Hollman Says:

    Hi, I’ve just now stumbled upon your website whilst I’m browsing around the Internet as I’m looking for some info on debt relief!. It’s a good site so I’ve bookmarked you and I intend to return tomorrow to have a proper browse when I can give it more time.

  14. sodomisez Says:

    Considerably, the post is in reality the best on this notable topic. I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your upcoming updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the great clarity in your writing. I will right away grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates. De lightful work and much success in your business endeavors!

  15. online stock trading advice Says:

    There’s good info here. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog. Keep up the good work mate!

    I’m Out! :)

  16. Condos Says:

    Hey Great Post! I totally agree with you and look forward to reading more of your posts

  17. Asley Hassanein Says:

    I sincerely got a kick out of your post. I don’t really have a lot to say in reply, I only wanted to comment to reply with wonderful work. great luck in 2010.

  18. Jamey Sorman Says:

    Does anyone have something else on this? I might would have an interest to be told a lot of concerning this as it’s all new to me

  19. Online casino us free Says:

    Online casinos us…

    play casino…

  20. Russell Yanda Says:

    I just discovered your webpage from Google. It has lots of very interesting details. I will definitely be bookmarking your site. Anyhow, pop over to my blog if you want to give up smoking.

  21. Constance Maeder Says:

    Their climber was so skilled it made taking down the diseased tree look easy. We have had some real winners?!?!?

  22. Lanell Benevento Says:

    Hi. Real good info on MLM Leads. I discovered your nice blog while researching bing. For the previous few days I have been seeking to discover more. Specially anything to do with the actual lead generation or companies making them. I’ve seen it all and my sister continues pressing her new lead system fad on me. So I’m glad I encountered you. Best regards!

  23. William Stanley Says:

    Do state databases for inmates have any protocols for connecting to each other so as to not miss an inmate having crimes from state to state?

  24. Miriam McDonald Says:

    I think this site is great. for someone like me who’s an adult but couldn’t read a note, let alone play the guitar, in just a couple weeks, i’ve learned to read music and play a number of chords and notes

  25. pumpkin17 Says:

    Vous cherchez des cours de musique ?

  26. Hana Dante Says:

    Would you kindly translate your website into German because I’m not that comfortable reading it in English? I’m getting tired of using Google Translate all the time, there is a little WordPress plugin called like global translator which will render all your pages automatically- this would make reading articleson your sweet blog even more comfortable. Cheers mate!

  27. Cousins d'amerique Says:

    Thank you for you post, here we learn about very well features. What you wrote is great advice any way that you look at it. :)

  28. Smoke Assassin Says:

    Can I use paypal to pay for this?

  29. criminal records Says:

    Interesting blog on Court Imposes Israeli Law on Gibraltar Gambling Website Omer Tene’s Blog, not like the other ones!

  30. Isaak Estes Says:

    Hi!
    Great post! Really inform people…

    Isaak Estes
    internet marketing website

  31. Israel Blocked Access to a range of IP Addresses : Legal Implications Says:

    […] clause 229. The first was the Carlton Case (CR 90861/07 Michael Gary Carlton v. Israeli Police, Dr. Omer Tene‘s explanation on Carlton) where the Israeli police requested to detain a foreign national who was involved in the operation […]

  32. carpet cleaning bournemouth Says:

    Great post! I’ve bookmarked this blog. Cheers Jason

  33. yurtdışı eğitim Says:

    Thank your labor healthhhhhn

  34. JarrodOD Says:

    http://effectsofdrugaddiction.org/ – effects of drug addiction

  35. Yurtdışı Eğitim Danışmanlığı Says:

    Gibraltar – an island of online gambling companies!

  36. new york drug rehab centers Says:

    Its such as you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, such as you wrote
    the guide in it or something. I believe that
    you could do with a few p.c. to power the message house a bit, but instead of that, this is
    great blog. A great read. I’ll certainly be back.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: